cabbage stew instead of cabbage soup?

Is it possible to replace the cabbage soup with cabbage, onion and carrot type stew and still experience the same weight loss?

Hello,
the impressive weight loss effect of the cabbage soup diet is closely related to the satiation effect and purifying properties of cabbage soup.
Both aspects can't be covered through cabbage stew.

But you might use cabbage stew as a dish on the so called "vegetable days" of the cabbage soup diet.

All the best,
Gabriela